Past and Present

 League Champions

2022 – Liberty Bible
2021 – United
2020 – Free Agents
2019 – Free Agents
2018 – Liberty Bible
2017 – Liberty Bible
2016 – Crosspoint
2015 – Crosspoint
2014 – Free Agents
2013 – Rock Creek
2012 – Crossroads United Methodist
2011 – Liberty Bible
2010 – Liberty Bible
2009 – New Castle
2008 – New Castle
2007 – New Castle
2006 – New Castle

Major Prophets Division Champions

2016 – Liberty Bible
2015 – Liberty Bible
2014 – Living Faith Fellowship
2013 – Liberty Bible

Minor Prophets Division Champions

2016 – New Castle
2015 – New Castle
2014 – Free Agents
2013 – Eureka Nazarene
2012 – Crossroads United Methodist
2011 – Living Faith Fellowship
2010 – Linn Mennonite
2009 – Cruger Township
2008 – Liberty Bible
2007 – Congerville Mennonite
2006 – Congerville Mennonite